PAPA JOE'S COLONIAL TOWN

Italian Dinner Menu

Full selection of traditional Italian entrees featuring house-made pasta, perfectly seasoned proteins, and rich sauces.

• Grilled chicken breast with signature seasoning
• Fresh pasta with homemade-style sauces
• Creamy Alfredo praised as 'the creamiest ever'

Pizza & Appetizers

Hand-crafted pizzas and appetizers including their famous garlic knots that customers rave about.

• Fresh-made pizza dough and quality toppings
• Perfect garlic knots with ideal texture
• Breadsticks that customers specifically praise

Dessert Selection

Traditional Italian desserts including fresh cannolis and specialty items like the Tuxedo Boome.

• Fresh, creamy cannolis made daily
• Tuxedo Boome signature dessert
• Perfect finishing touches to complete meals

Pre-Theater Dining

Convenient location and timing perfect for dinner before shows at nearby Santikos Theatre.

• Strategic location near entertainment district
• Efficient service for theater schedules
• Popular choice for date nights and family outings

“Our waitress Kim was very friendly, helped us out with any question we had. We appreciate her for the service she gave us and the friendly attitude she had. 100% recommend the food here, it was all delicious. The Grilled Chicken Breast meal was on top with flavor! The seasoning was absolutely perfect. The Tuxedo Boome was a delicious way to end dinner. Thank you so much, Kim and all the chefs that were here tonight!”

“I thoroughly enjoy the pizza at Papa Joes. The cook (Miguel) does an excellent job with all of the food. The service from Kim is always outstanding. My wife and I have been going there for more than 15 years and it never disappoints. I highly recommend this as a great dining experience before a movie at Santikos Theatre in Lake Mary. 👍”

“The food was delicious — fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. The pasta I ordered tasted homemade, the sauce was rich and balanced, and the portion just perfect. My daughter had the Alfredo and devoured it. She said it was the creamiest Alfredo she’s ever had. The garlic knots were amazing! Who is even complaining about those? They were PERFECT. Every dish felt like it was made with real care. The dessert was the perfect finishing touch, especially the cannolis, they were light, creamy, and fresh. Our waiter and staff were very friendly and attentive. Overall, this restaurant exceeded my expectations in every way. If you’re looking for amazing Italian food paired with great service this is the place to go. Highly recommend!”

“I’ve been going to Papa Joe’s for nearly 20 years, and hands down, they have the best spaghetti and pizza in Central Florida. The food is always amazing, and the staff makes you feel like family. Huge thanks to Mike G for always taking great care of me and my family—we truly appreciate it. I make sure to stop by for a pizza whenever I’m in town. Highly recommended!!”